Frontera Small Logo

 Frontera NorteSur
April 2002

 CIUDAD JUAREZ & CHIHUAHUA NEWS

April 25, 2002
Cd. Juárez Waste Water: Treatment Plants May Lack Chlorine, Stench Hits El Paso

On April 22, 2002 the Ciudad Juárez newspaper El Diario printed a full-page article on the lack of chlorine in the city's sewage treatment process. An investigation by the newspaper claims that the city's water utility, JMAS, is trying to save money by not using chlorine in the treatment of waste water. If El Diario's allegations are true, this would mean that JMAS is in violation of health safety regulations as put forth in the Norma Oficial Mexicana.

"We don't have any chlorine at this time . . . only 36 empty tanks," said Mario Arredondo Calderón, shift supervisor at the city's northern waste-water treatment plant, on March 10, 2002.

Jorge Jaime Alvarez Gutiérrez, head of JMAS's purchasing department, said that the only order for chlorine that he is putting through at this time is for 202 tons of the material. However, according to El Diario, this chlorine is destined for treating water from the city's 240 drinking-water wells--not for waste-water treatment.

The El Diario article went on to say that although local officials are denying that the city's sewage-treatment process lacks chlorine, the US side of the International Boundary and Water Commission (IBWC) has noted problems with waste-water chlorine levels.

Sally Spener, IBWC spokesperson, was quoted as saying that JMAS's own water-quality data shows that, during certain periods, waste water from the Cd. Juárez treatment plants is high in fecal coliform bacteria. This means that the treatment plants are not working as they should in regards to chlorination.

In the April 25 El Diario, Ignacio Duarte Murillo, president of the JMAS, responded to the above claims by saying that there has always been a sufficient amount of chlorine to cover the city's needs. He suggested that the April 22 El Dario article was run for political reasons, eluding perhaps to the upcoming May elections for Cd. Juárez mayor.

Stench from treatment plants

What no one in the region is denying is that Cd. Juárez sewage plants lack multi-stage treatments that eliminate odors stemming from the purification process. These odors affect El Paso when the wind carries them into the US.

A number of Cd. Juárez health and water officials told the El Paso Times that their city is aware of the odor problem and is trying to resolve it. The city is hoping to plant odor-absorbing trees and to use chemicals that would stop the problem at its source at the treatment facilities. Cd. Juárez is also looking for grants and loans to add the secondary treatment which would eliminate odors.


Bonnie Johnson, a 71-year old, El Paso resident that has lived just yards from the border for 39 years, told the El Paso Times that "For the past couple months, when I would take my walk, I would smell a putrid decaying animal or body and I would look for one. Then I realized that the smell wasn't a decaying animal but . . . the sewage plant across the river."

Antonio Valenzuela, another El Paso resident affected by the odor from water treatment facilities in Cd. Juárez, said "The other day the smell was so bad my grandchildren refused to eat, and it's getting worse. I can't turn on the air conditioner because it just sucks the smell in."

Sources: El Diario, April 22 & 25, 2002. Articles by Pablo Hernández Batista.
El Paso Times, April 25, 2002. Article by Laura Cruz.

April 18, 2002
Victims' Mothers Take Over Chihuahua Capitol Building

Twenty-one mothers of serial-killing victims from Ciudad Juárez and Chihuahua took over the Chihuahua State capitol on Tuesday, April 16, 2002, according to an article in the Cd. Juárez newspaper, El Norte.

The mothers were heard by a special commission of deputies (the US equivalent of representatives) from most Chihuahua political parties. Later, after some initial scheduling difficulties and threats made by the mothers, they were given a fifteen-minute appointment with Governor Patricio Martínez. That meeting ended up lasting two hours, according to the El Norte article.

At the Congress

In front of the Congress, Norma Ledezma, the mother of Paloma Angélica Escobar Ledezma who was raped and murdered in Chihuahua City in March 2002, told Chihuahua deputies "You listen to us, but you don't hear us. We need you to go beyond red tape, beyond one day of much publicity, one day of long articles in the newspapers . . . Today we want you to hear us."

One unnamed mother told the legislature, "We hope for solutions and no more promises. We've come to Congress to ask for solutions but soon we won't come here anymore, we'll take more drastic actions."

Another mother said, "They know who they are [the killers] but they don't do anything because they are covering up for someone."

The mothers' demands

In a document sent to the Congress, the mothers asked for the following:

1. That government authorities put all means available into stopping crimes against women. ENOUGH! Authorities have an obligation to act;

2. The immediate recovery of all young missing women, that are alive, that have disappeared from Cd. Juárez, Chihuahua City and every corner of the state;

3. Rapid results in investigations and a public presentation about all those involved, no matter who is involved and no matter who falls from power because of this. We won't accept scapegoats who are being used to cover for the real killers;

4. Sufficient money and opportunity for the investigation of disappearances and crimes against women including special agents, experts, criminologists, an immediate alert system for disappeared women and those thought responsible for the crimes, and a DNA laboratory in Cd. Juárez; and

5. The appearance of the Attorney General before the Congress to inform on investigations that have taken place so far.

Deputies respond

The meeting with Chihuahua deputies lasted one and half hours and the deputies made several proposals to the mothers. They agreed to propose to the full Congress that more funds be given to Cd. Juárez law enforcement and that the Instituto Mexicano del Seguro Social change its laws and provide better benefits to survivors as some only receive 200 pesos per month (approximately US$22).

The special commission of deputies also promised to ask the Federal Attorney General's Office to accept DNA evidence that comes from private labs. This is linked to demands for independent DNA analysis made by some of the mothers that do not trust any results coming from government labs.

The special commission of deputies was comprised of Martha Laguette Lardizábal (PRI), Alma Delia Urrutia Canizales (PRI), Elsy Paz Quintana (PAN), Héctor Barraza Chávez (PRD) and Jorge Arrellanes Moreno (PT).

Like some of the victims' mothers, many of the deputies were in tears as they spoke. Urrutia explained to the mothers what the Congress had done so far in terms of helping with the issue of disappeared women and what it can and cannot do in the future.

Laguette said to the mothers, "you came to make demands, and you have the right to do so, continue demanding justice . . . don't be afraid of anything."

The governor responds

Jesús Antonio Piñón Jiménez, the assistant attorney general for the state, was called into the meeting with the mothers by the governor himself. In front of the mothers, Governor Martínez instructed Piñón to give the mothers' daughters' cases individual attention.

The governor also spoke about crime in Cd. Juárez and ordered the creation of a state organization that will assist families of the disappeared to locate their missing relatives. The group will begin in Chihuahua City and will then have an office in Cd. Juárez, he said.

Governor Martínez also said that a DNA lab will be set up in Cd. Juárez but he was not sure when. Later, he invited the mothers to tour the state police office in Chihuahua City that same day.

Source: El Norte, April 17, 2002. Article by Rodrigo Ramírez.

April 15, 2002
Former INS Inspector Guilty in Marijuana Case

Raymond Monroe Allen, 40, a former INS inspector in El Paso plead guilty on Thursday, April 11 to charges of conspiracy to import marijuana and to charges of money laundering. Monroe now faces ten years to life in prison after admitting that while on duty he used cell phones, pagers and radios to help get drug shipments across El Paso's Bridge of the Americas.

An article in the El Paso times states that authorities believe that Allen and five others were responsible for bringing into the US approximately 164,000 pounds of marijuana since 1999.

Allen's wife, Maria Luisa Olivas Allen, pleaded guilty to one charge of money laundering in March. She could receive a sentence of up to twenty years in prison at her sentencing on May 17.

Also arrested in connection with the case were two Ciudad Juárez residents, Alfredo Silva Olivas and Arturo Laredo Molinar. They also plead guilty on April 11 and face penalties ranging from five years to life in prison.

Authorities are still looking for two more Cd. Juárez residents who were allegedly involved in the case, Martín Martínez Rueda and Jesus Acosta.

Source: El Paso Times, April 12, 2002. Article by Laura Cruz.

April 12, 2002
Computer School in Juárez and Chihuahua City Under Investigation for Murder of Women

An article in the April 7, 2002 El Paso Times states that Chihuahua state police are investigating ECCO computer schools in connection with the murders of several young women in Ciudad Juárez and Chihuahua City, according to David Diaz, state police spokesperson.

At least eight young women who were murdered or reported missing over the past few years attended, or had looked into attending, ECCO schools. ECCO has 36 branches including Ciudad Juárez, Chihuahua City and other states

Octavio De La Torre Jimenez, director of the Cd. Juárez ECCO school, located on Avenida 16 de Septiembre, and Aaron Anibal Castañeda, director of the Chihuahua City ECCO, told the El Paso Times that there was no wrongdoing on the part of ECCO.

According to an article in El Diario, on April 6, 2002, at least two ECCO employees are among the suspects in the Chihuahua City killing of 17-year-old Paloma Escobar. Escobar was reported missing at the beginning of March, 2002.

The El Paso Times article went on to look at ECCO connections with murdered young women in Cd. Juárez.

Liliana Holguin de Santiago's body was found in 2000. She was 15 at the time of her death and attended ECCO. She also worked across the street from ECCO on a part-time basis.

Lilia Alejandra García, 17, attended ECCO. She was abducted on February 14, 2001. Police said she was held alive for approximately two days before she was murdered. She was abducted after leaving work.

Maria Acosta Ramírez, 19, worked at a Philips maquiladora and was last seen on April 25, 2001 leaving ECCO. Her body was one of eight found in a field in November, 2001.

Esmeralda Herrera Monreal, 15, had met with ECCO recruiters at her house a few days before her death. She was one of eight young women found in the cotton field in November, 2001.

Cd. Juárez women's rights activists have pointed out to Frontera NorteSur that Acosta's, Holguin's and Herrera's cases have already been closed because of the arrest of bus drivers Víctor Javier García Uribe and Gustavo González Meza. How this affects the investigation of ECCO employees is unknown at this time.

García and González have both repeatedly stated that they were tortured and coerced into confessing to the murder of Acosta, Holguin, Herrera and eight other women.

Earlier this year, El Diario reported that Oscar Maynez, the state police evidence expert, resigned from the state police because he was asked to fabricate evidence against the two men.

Source: El Paso Times, April 7, 2002. Article by Diana Washington Valdez.

April 3, 2002
Murders Go Unresolved in Cd. Juárez, State Evidence Expert Fired for Drug Links

In the first three months of 2002, there have been 85 homicides in Ciudad Juárez, 80% of which have not been solved by the Chihuahua State Police which is in charge of murder investigations, according to the Ciudad Juárez newspaper, El Diario. While the number of murders is higher than usual because of two families that perished in arson attacks, the apprehension rate for Chihuahua law enforcement is still low.

Grupo Zeus, which is responsible for solving drug-related murders, has not solved any of the 15 narco-related killings that have occurred so far this year, according to the El Diario article. Similarly, the State Police's Homicide Department has 70% of its cases still open.

The most effective state police group in closing murder cases has been the Office of the Special Investigator for Women's Murders. Five of nine cases have been solved by this group. However, the office has been under constant criticism since last year when it solved eleven rape murder cases by arresting two bus drivers who later said they were tortured into making false confessions.

In a separate story, the head of the state police evidence lab was fired in late March for not revealing that he had been fired from the same organization in 1991 after being arrested for drug trafficking and weapons violations. Héctor Enrique Infante Silva, the director of the evidence lab and service, was fired on March 27, 2002. On January 31, 2002, El Diario ran an article about Infante's 1991 arrest when he was caught with a one kilogram sample of marijuana, a stolen vehicle from El Paso, over US$5,000 and an Uzi submachine gun, among other things.

Source: El Diario, April 2, 2002. Article by Armando Rodríguez. El Diario, March 28, 2002.

March 26, 2002
Cut in Drug Flow Sparks Weekend Prison Riot in Juárez, One Prisoner Dead

More than 500 inmates rioted at a prison near Ciudad Juárez on Saturday, March 23. One prisoner, 35 year old Sergio Arturo Madrid Herrera, was killed by a bullet fired by a law-enforcement agent. The bullet struck Madrid in the back of the head, according to state law enforcement officials who are investigating Madrid's death.

In their attempt to quell the riot, 44 prisoners were sent by prison officials from the Cd. Juárez-area prison, known as the Cereso, to a similar facility about 250 miles south near Chihuahua City.

The head of the prison, Luis Arturo Barragán González, was fired from his job and is being investigated for links to drug sales that take place in the facility, according to Guillermo Dowell Delgado, a Cd. Juárez city official.

El Diario, a Cd. Juárez newspaper, attributed the riot to the prison administration's decision to stop the flow of drugs into the Cereso. According to the newspaper, inmates began rioting after some of them started to experience symptoms of physical withdrawal from drugs.

Sergio Gallardo, a family member of one of the inmates, said that prisoners "have always had drugs both inside and outside, I don't know why they would take them away now."

A mother of one of the inmates told El Diario that the riot was the fault of prison officials because, "They get the inmates addicted to drugs and then they take the crap away from them."

A number of police units in anti-riot gear entered the prison to restore order. Describing their tactics, one journalist wrote that he saw a dozen prisoners with their hands handcuffed behind them and face down on the floor. When the drugged inmates could not stand up to form a line, one agent went up to all the prisoners and sprayed their faces with tear gas and punched them before leaving.

That the men had already received drugs is possible, according to the words of one witness. Jovita
Morales was inside the prison visiting her brother when the riot began. She said that the prisoners
started pulling down a fence to protest the lack of drugs.

Morales said that guards then began throwing little packets of drugs to the prisoners. Once they
were high and sedated, she said, city police entered the Cereso and began beating prisoners in front of the visitors. They were stripped, handcuffed and beaten again, according to Morales.

Source: El Diario, March 24 & 25, 2002.